In the Middle of the Night, a Neighbor Knocked on My Door – I Still Regret Letting Him In

I thought I was being a good neighbor when Nate, who’d moved in next door a couple of weeks ago, knocked on my door at 2 AM. He claimed a pipe had burst and he needed a place to stay. I let him in, but something felt off.

The next morning, I discovered Nate’s lie. His supposedly flooded house was fine, and he was with another woman, Vanessa, who was married to a Navy officer, Ryan. I felt angry and used, an accessory to their affair.

Ryan came to my door, suspicious of his wife’s activities, and I had to lie again to cover for Nate and Vanessa. I felt guilty and trapped in their web of deceit. I demanded $500 from Nate for my silence and promised to stay out of it if he ended things with Vanessa.

As Nate left, I realized I’d gotten tangled in a mess. I’d lied to an innocent man and blackmailed another. The quiet suburban street seemed full of secrets and lies. I’d tried to be a good neighbor, but it had cost me my peace of mind.

“I didn’t know what else to do. I was desperate,” Nate said. “You won’t see me again,” he promised, as he left my house for the last time. I hoped so, for all our sakes.